Ten gym facilities across New York, Brooklyn, and Middle Village make this list. These venues include sport clubs, health clubs, specialized studios, university athletic facilities, and community recreation centers. Ratings for these locations range from 4.2 to 4.9 stars, based on a combined total of over 3,900 user reviews. The facilities offer a variety of environments, from harbor-view complexes and community-focused centers to studios specializing in heavy lifting and university gyms with rock walls.
Rankings are determined by multiplying the star rating by the logarithm of the review count, with no paid placements.
1. Chelsea Piers
Located at 62 Chelsea Piers in New York, this venue holds a 4.5 rating from 828 reviews. Visitors highlight the beautiful view of the harbor and recommend the harbor cruise for a different point of view.
2. BYKlyn Studios
This Brooklyn studio has a 4.9 rating based on 277 reviews. Members describe the space as inviting with encouraging peers and friendly staff. The Lifting Heavy class with Brennan is specifically noted for quality feedback on form.
3. FitNation Health Club
Based in Middle Village, this health club maintains a 4.4 rating from 523 reviews. Users describe the gym as spacious and clean, noting that manager Selena and personal trainer Santi are helpful and flexible.
4. Red Hook Recreation Center
With a 4.3 rating from 578 reviews, this Brooklyn center is recommended for both adults and kids. The facility includes an indoor gym, basketball court, and an inside track for jogging, with machines described as clean and like new.
5. Manhattan Plaza Health Club
This New York facility has a 4.2 rating from 552 reviews. While the staff is described as fantastic and kind, one reviewer noted a shortage of stair masters compared to the number of available stationary bikes.
6. Chelsea Piers Fitness
Located at 60 Chelsea Piers in New York, this gym has a 4.3 rating from 322 reviews. Feedback mentions updated equipment and an amazing-looking pool.
7. The 14th Street Y
This New York venue holds a 4.3 rating from 318 reviews. Members value the price and the fact that their membership supports a center that serves the local community.
8. Asser Levy Recreation Center
Located at 392 Asser Levy Pl in New York, this recreation center has a 4.2 rating based on 322 reviews.
9. NYU Palladium Athletic Facility
This New York facility has a 4.3 rating from 207 reviews. It features a gym, swimming pool, and rock wall, with on-site food options including poke, sushi, and philly cheesesteaks.
10. Sportspark Athletic Complex
Located at 250 Main St in New York, this athletic complex holds a 4.4 rating from 183 reviews.
How we ranked these
Our rankings are based on a calculation of rating multiplied by the log of the review count to balance quality and popularity. For more details, see our methodology.